Pressing reset to start is required since the Apple 1 didn't have an auto-reset circuit, neither does the replica 1.
It isn't the keyboard controller, or RAM because you would still get a reset "\" response anyways. It isn't the max233 because that isn't required for a reset to work either. Same thing as with the ATMEGA8515, even if it was removed, it would still display a \ when you hit reset.
Check the orientation of your oscillator. Pin 1 is the pointed corner and faces the max233 chip.
It could be, CPU, 6821, oscillator, EPROM (I tested all shipped) as well as any of the 3 glue logic chips 74LS00, 04 or 138.
Check your main clock signal first, pin 37 is the pin on the 6502 that recieves the 1MHz clock from the oscillator. Check to make sure that has a frequency of 1MHz. If you don't have a way to measure frequency that is ok, just check the voltage. It should be around 2.3 to 2.6V because it is oscillating at 1 million times a second.
Next, check the RESET line. When you hit reset, it should drop down to 0V until you release the button, then it should go back up to 5V.
Then check the Sync line on the 6502 (pin 7) and read what that is registering.
You can go through all the Address lines and see what address it is pointing to and see if they change with a reset. record your addresses.
I would focus on the oscillator (make sure your boards heart-beat is working), then check the sync signal and see if that is working.
That should give you some homework for a while. Remember, don't get frustrated, my first replica didn't work but I knew I could get it going. After some work, it did and here we are today
I also offer a free up and running program where I will get your replica running but I like people to try first. I have the luxury of having chips available to swap out so it's easier for me to work on. Plus I know how the replica 1 should react.
I've had a few people send theirs in and 50% of the time it is a missed solder pin on a socket. The other 50% was a defective chip. Unfortunately I can't test all the chips, only the programmed ones, so like most kits, there is a risk of a defective chip.
Let's see what you find first.
Vince